Your mother has lived in a nursing home outside Charleston since her hip surgery. On a Sunday visit you find a pressure sore on her heel that wasn’t there before. The aide who helps you turn her says she has been covering the whole hall by herself since Thursday. You drive home angry at the aide, which is understandable, but she is probably the last person in the company who had any say on how people worked that hall.
So, who can be held liable for nursing home neglect? In West Virginia, the answer usually starts at the bedside and climbs from there. A Charleston nursing home neglect lawyer can sort out which people and companies belong in your mother’s case. Here’s who might have to answer for that sore and what it takes to prove it.
The Aide Has a Boss, and the Boss Answers for Her
The aide, the nurse who signs your mother’s chart, and the therapist who sees her twice a week are all employees of the home. Under a rule called vicarious liability, an employer answers for the carelessness of its employees while they’re doing their jobs.
Nobody has to prove that the company itself did anything wrong. If the aide missed a turn on your mother’s schedule because she had 20 other residents to get to, the company that signs her paycheck owes for the harm that followed. Most families aim at the employer instead of the aide, since the company carries the insurance and it set the schedule that left one aide alone on the hall.
Follow the License Up to the Owners
The name on the sign out front isn’t always the company that actually runs the place. Nursing home ownership structure tends to come in layers, with one company holding the license, another owning the building, and a third managing the money.
A federal study of nursing home ownership found that real estate investment trusts had money in roughly 9 percent of the country’s nursing homes in 2022, and private equity firms were invested in another 5 percent.
Those layers matter in your mother’s case because the decisions that left her aide alone were probably made way above her head. Somebody at the company set the staffing budget for that hall and decided how much training a new aide gets before she works it alone. When choices like that lead to a sore like your mother’s, lawyers call it corporate negligence, and the company answers its own decisions as well as its employees’ mistakes.
West Virginia’s Medical Professional Liability Act covers a home’s “related entities,” meaning companies that own any part of the home or share ownership with it. So, a parent company can be sued under the same law as the home when there’s proof it had a hand in those decisions. You can look up your mother’s home on Medicare’s Care Compare site, which shows the owners the government has on file.
Not Everyone in the Building Works for the Home
Some of the people who treat your mother are outside contractors. The pharmacy that fills her prescriptions, the wound care consultant, the hospice agency, and even the home’s medical director are often separate businesses or independent physicians. Each one answers for its own mistakes. If a wound nurse from an outside company spotted that bedsore two weeks ago and never wrote an order, her company could share the blame with the home.
Whether the home also has to pay for a contractor’s mistake is a harder question. Families sometimes argue that the contractor looked like staff, and West Virginia law shuts that argument down when the contractor carries at least $1 million in liability insurance for the injury. Expect your mother’s lawyer to name each outside company in the lawsuit in its own right.
Equipment works the same way. If your mother’s sore traces back to a pressure-relief mattress that stopped inflating, its manufacturer can be liable for a defective product even if the staff did everything correctly.
The Law Wants a Second Opinion Before It Wants a Lawsuit
Suing a nursing home for neglect in West Virginia isn’t like suing over a car wreck. Under the Medical Professional Liability Act, you have to show that the home or the contractor failed to give your mother the care a reasonable, prudent provider would have given in the same situation. You also must show that the specific failure caused her injury.
The law also adds a step before the courthouse. At least 30 days before filing, your lawyer has to send each defendant a notice of claim with a screening certificate of merit, which is a sworn statement from a qualified health care provider explaining how the care fell short. Every company and person you plan to sue gets a separate certificate, so the list of defendants has to be worked out early. A nursing home negligence lawsuit in West Virginia generally has to be filed within one year of the injury or when you reasonably should have discovered, which is half the time most injury claims get.
If the home ran that hall below the state’s minimum staffing level, the law presumes its residents weren’t adequately supervised unless the home can prove otherwise. It presumes the opposite when the home met the minimum. Write down the dates you saw the hall short-handed and the names of the aides who told you so while you still remember them.
Start With the Sore and Let Us Find the Rest
The sore on your mother’s heel started with a missed turn, but the reasons it was missed can run through a staffing budget, a management contract, and a company you’ve never even heard of. At Forbes Law Offices, our firm’s West Virginia trial lawyers bring more than 75 years of experience to tracing neglect back through those layers. We line up the medical reviewers the law requires and send the notices to every company that shares the blame.
If someone you love was hurt in a long-term care facility, reach out to our firm for a free consultation. Bring the photos you took, the names of the staff you talked to, and any paperwork the home gave you, and we’ll start working out who was responsible for her care.